New rules for winning in a downturn.
CFOs have the opportunity to play a crucial role in sustaining growth in times of volatility.
Financial discipline and growth are not mutually exclusive; balancing the two requires thinking differently about how and where to spend.
Going remote, distributed, and global may help solve your talent needs and yield cost-savings at the same time.
Prioritizing products and projects with the greatest ROI — and your core customers — can accelerate your path to profitability.
“You still have to play to win — and win big.”
— Lee Kirkpatrick, former CFO of Twilio
As companies face a downturn whose severity and duration no one can predict, pundits everywhere are preaching prudence and austerity. It’s sound advice.
And yet, at Brex we believe that today’s macroeconomic climate calls for something more nuanced — a world where empowered CFOs and finance teams can help foster a delicate balance between financial discipline and growth.
We are not alone. We’ve asked leaders in the CFO community — those who have survived past downturns and those who are on the frontlines today — for their insights on how to navigate these uncertain times. While there is no single playbook that will work for every company, we believe the insights that follow can provide guideposts for companies to not only survive but thrive.
“What we’re telling our portfolio companies is that, yes, this is a great time to be prudent and to think about cost measures and right-sizing burn,” says Mark Goldberg, a partner at San Francisco-based Index Ventures. “This isn't 2021. But it's also probably not the right time to be taking your foot off the gas if you're doing well.”
An economic downturn unlike any other.
While past downturns provide some guidance for how to thread that needle, some things are different this time around. Markets are down and capital has become more expensive, but the labor market remains tight, and consumers and businesses keep buying.
“We’re not seeing a massive pullback in consumer spending or B2B enterprise spending,” says Lee Kirkpatrick, former CFO of Twilio and Ofoto, which he managed through the dotcom crash. “What we're seeing is a pullback in the ability to raise capital.” Because of these conditions, Kirkpatrick, who serves on multiple company boards, worries companies will overcorrect by slamming on the brakes. Instead, they should be figuring out how to be smarter about their spending. “You still have to play to win — and win big,” he adds.
So how should CFOs lead in the current climate? These ideas can provide guidance for how to instill financial discipline across the organization while sustaining growth.
Don’t try to cut your way to profitability.
Investors still have plenty of capital to put to work, but most are no longer willing to fund businesses that don’t have a clear path to generating free cash flow or becoming profitable. That’s why it’s become critical for companies to demonstrate to everyone from current investors to potential suitors that they can run a lean operation.
“Investors are looking at how companies are weathering the storm,” says Joseph Gwozdz, a veteran CFO who is now an operating partner at Edison Partners, a growth equity firm. “How are they dealing with inflation and talent shortages, and the like, and do they understand you can’t spend money like crazy.”
But trying to cut your way to profitability is fraught. While it may provide some short-term relief, it’s unlikely to lead to long-term success. Danielle Murcray, CFO of cybersecurity company AttackIQ, says savvy finance teams will focus on sales and marketing efficiency rather than cuts. “You can cut marketing spend as much as you want, it’s never going to get you to where you need to be,” she says. Instead, the focus should be on how much revenue and profit those marketing investments are able to generate, she says.
“You can cut marketing spend as much as you want; it’s never going to get you to where you need to be.”
— Danielle Murcray, CFO, AttackIQ
Go remote, distributed, and global.
Top talent has always been distributed around the globe, but many companies have been hesitant to hire employees in distant locations. The move to hybrid and remote work has helped many get past that hesitation. Going remote, distributed, and global is an opportunity to better navigate the talent crunch — for instance, by tapping locations that offer an abundance of skills in a particular area — and to generate cost-savings at the same time.
One way to achieve this is by encouraging managers to think in terms of budgets rather than headcount, says Michael Tannenbaum, CFO and COO of Brex. “If I give an engineering lead a budget of $10 million, it can mean very different headcounts if it's a US-funded team versus international team, and it forces them to make a trade-off.”
“When you give them a budget, you're introducing scarcity, and the engineering manager will say, ‘I need horsepower here. I'm going to go fill 40% of that budget in India at a ratio of five-to-one versus what I can get in the US for that same dollar amount.’”
The decision to go global should be easier now that a proliferation of cloud-based tools for everything from communications to accounting and resource management have made it easier — and sometimes, cheaper — to onboard and collaborate with employees from anywhere.
Focus on core areas with high ROI — and core customers.
Many companies try to be all things to all people, but not every customer is necessarily a good fit. Taking a broad view on your customer market risks increasing churn and could be costly in the long run. A better strategy for these times is to focus on pleasing — and retaining — the customers that best align with your core mission.
At Brex, Tannenbaum has developed a framework for ranking priorities based on a set of criteria laid out on a matrix. On one axis, he says, is the company’s mission and how closely an investment would be tied to the core product. On the other axis are less tangible criteria such as customer happiness.
“Ultimately, it will translate to financials. Customer success and financials are very closely correlated,” he says.
Similarly, not all products and projects will yield the same return on investment. So instead of doing 10 projects, for example, it may make sense to focus on the top five and put spend and staff against those.
“You can still fund growth initiatives, but you stage the investment, and you release more investment once you have more proof points,” says Tannenbaum.
Help employees think like owners.
This will go a long way toward developing a culture where workers are aware of budgets and think like an owner about their own resources. Another benefit of this approach: Workers across the company often know best where wasteful spending is taking place.
Consider acqui-hires to foster growth.
Such deals can be a cost-efficient way to grow not only your product or customer base, but also your staff through “acqui-hires,” where you buy a company primarily for its people. Often, these people have subject matter expertise and may even have built a product that can dramatically accelerate your company’s organic roadmap.
Take a look at active treasury management.
With interest rates rising, you might also take a new view on the money you have in the bank. Higher interest rates increase the cost of borrowing, but it also means higher returns on the money you are saving. If you’re a billion-dollar company, even 3% is a meaningful return — enough for those acquisition opportunities or other growth investments.
Keep playing to win.
While the approaches outlined above may be right for the times, it doesn’t mean companies should be rigid about following them. Indeed, Tannenbaum says CFOs can be most valuable when they are intentionally flexible: dynamic planning allows them, and the whole organization, to respond with agility in different situations. “It’s a way to still find growth, but do it in a healthier and more sustainable way,” Tannenbaum says.